Break All the Rules

Photo by puja

A couple months ago, I met with a slightly older (Gen X) male colleague of mine and we sat down discussing our nonprofit careers and where we wanted to end up within the sector. He shared about his work in starting a new nonprofit in DC and I told him about my blog, speaking engagements, and everything I was trying to do with raising the voice of the next generation and promoting leadership and professional development for the sector. He kind of smirked a little, and told me to slow my roll because, “You think you know everything, but you don’t. Don’t walk around here so full of yourself.” Well, you can imagine how encouraging THAT conversation was. Here was a colleague, a peer of mine even, telling me to play by the rules. I had opened up to share my passion about changing the future of the sector, and got smacked down by the pay-your-dues police. I guess some people just don’t believe in supporting their peers. Which is funny, because we all will need support at some point in time, and it’s best not to burn your bridges. And for him, this bridge is totally burnt baby.

One of the things we talked about at the Next Wave Action Summit last week was that younger generations, while we didn’t participate in the Civil Rights or Womens Rights movements, we have lived long enough to see the failures of government, business, and nonprofits to operate in ways that don’t really work to make this world a better place. We’ve experienced the horribly ineffective and embarrassing Bush administration, the horror of Hurricane Katrina and the mistreatment of its victims, 9/11 and a senseless war killing young soldiers in Iraq. There’s a lot for us to be riled up about in this country, and the most ambitious of us get riled up enough to change these systems or do something to prevent injustice or help people who are suffering in our society.

So who are you to hold anyone back? This country needs all the do-gooders we can get! I may be only 25 years old, but I have a vision for change just like my older counterparts. The only difference is that I’m not at all interested in playing by the rules.

And what are these rules anyway? There seems to be this crazy sentiment in our ever professionalized sector that there’s a certain order to things (just check out any nonprofit job description):

  • Get a Bachelors degree in social work, political science, or business
  • Work as an intern or assistant for pennies at least 2 years
  • Burnout on PB&J and get your next job as a coordinator or associate for 2 more years while you finish your Masters degree in social work, political science, or business
  • Then find a gig as a manager and learn everything on the job for about 3 years
  • Congratulations! With 7 years of experience, now you can qualify as senior management, director-level material!

Well, I think these rules suck. Why should anyone have to wait 7 years to be recognized as a leader in their organizations? This is the path I took:

  • Got a Bachelors degree in English, worked as a part-time fundraiser at nonprofits during college
  • Worked as an assistant for pennies and learned everything on the job for one year out of college while I finished my Masters degree in Nonprofit Management
  • Burned out on PB&J and got my next job in a director position at a small nonprofit
  • Created a blog and got myself a reputation as a leader
  • Began speaking out about the issues I care about, started receiving invitations to make presentations in DC, Virginia, Boston, Georgia, Minnesota
  • Started a business providing management consulting and training for small nonprofits
  • Just accepted an adjunct faculty position at Trinity University in DC!

So what I’ve learned from my experiences is so contrary to what my male colleague tried to tell me. I’ve learned that sometimes playing by the rules doesn’t get you anywhere. It doesn’t empower you to act on what you believe in because you’re just waiting for someone to notice your work and give you permission to be a leader. But when you put yourself out there – even though you know damn well you might fail – the universe responds positively to help you achieve your goals. Our communities need people who aren’t just going through the motions waiting for the world to change. We need people who are courageous enough to push out of the box and come up with new and improved ways of doing nonprofit work. We need people that are willing to break all the rules.

What’s been YOUR experience?

  • NoHeroine

    It is important to know the typical path and rules of any sector you work in (as you clearly do). This lets you know the “where and how” to push the limits. ‘Know thine enemy’

    Congratulations on evaluating the system and figuring out how to beat it!!!

    I’m 25 also, and love working in the NP sector. I get frustrated often. Not being taken seriously because of your experience, but mostly your age, is a tough pill to swallow.

    I believe that people should earn credibility based on their actions, their passion, and their work… not some time limit. You’d think the NP sector would understand that more than any other. It’s not only young people with great ideas being held back, but sometimes its its entrenched directors with years of experience and old ideas who refuse to give way because they ‘know it all.’ Maybe it’s just being a Millenial, but we should all be working together…collaborating!

    Young non-profit professionals eager to move ahead should value themselves enough to find work where they are treated as contributors. As you said “because you’re worth it.” Plus it’s better for the sector to put your time and energy where it is most useful.

    Finally, it’s important to remember that while you are wasting time paying you dues, someone might already be taking that leadership position you had your eye on.

    If you don’t demand respect, you won’t get it.

  • Cali_Mom

    I’m not in the non-profit sector, but I do believe in blazing your own trail. Congrats to you on finding your own way. I am looking into learning more about non-profits and how they are run. While I don’t have any interest right now in starting one on my own, I’m always looking for organizations to support. Keep up the great work! I love your blog.

  • Akira

    Amen!

  • Rosetta Thurman

    Welcome CaliMom! Thanks for reading. I hope you find some good organizations to support – we need you!

    Amen NoHeroine! I love your philosophy that people should be evaluated on their merit, not their age. It’s high time the nonprofit sector switched gears! Also, it’s a good warning for emerging leaders that, “someone might already be taking that leadership position you had your eye on.” Time waits for no one!

  • JobSage

    Rosetta, I just happened across your blog for the first time this morning. It’s great to see that there’s still a passionate few of us who aren’t afraid of all those “rules” put in place by the generations before us. Your thoughts on being in a position to lead at our age are encouraging, as I myself am struggling with the obstacle of older “know-it-alls”.
    I just want to add that it is not only non-profits that need to change gears (though they seem to stumble more than for-profits). I work as a Senior Consultant at a firm specializing in human resources, and consistently run into cross-generational issues. I’m all for earning your stripes, but if we want the workforce to be manageable once the baby boomers settle into retirement, we need to start “cutting the fat” now. Get rid of paperwork, stereotypes, and powertrips – we need to be productive and efficient to handle the workload of a growing population with a shrinking workforce.

  • James Walker

    Hi Rosetta,

    Great post! I am a very big believer in the idea that people need to chart their own course. There’s the traditional way, but that may not be the best way for you.

    Congrats on the position at Trinity! Teaching part-time is definitely a goal of mine. Hope they realize what a great professor they’re about to have!

  • The 6

    Being an adjunct professor was the ONLY thing you weren’t doing, that I wanted to do. So now that you’ve effectively stolen my life, I’d like to say CONGRATULATIONS on the new professor position! J/k… it’s extremely refreshing to see ANYONE in our generation with passion for ANY subject. I’m 26 and a new entrant to the non profit sector. I’m also a firm believer that if one matches passion with action, both success and positive change are inevitable! And it looks as if this is definitely proving to be true in your case. Keep up the great work you’re doing. Love the blog!

  • Anonymous

    All this shows is those who “can do” do, and those who “can’t do” teach.

    As a director in a non-profit who did pay the dues, I can tell you that the value of time in roles is invaluable.

    No one should assume that good ideas and raw talent alone prepare you for leadership.

  • JobSage

    I’m sure I speak for many when I say we are aware that our talent and good ideas need some maturing, which is why we push for mentoring. However paying “the dues” is no longer a feasible option at a time when demand is quickly outrunning supply.

    If the world was running out of water, we would have to sustain ourselves alternatively – the same is true for our workforce. We need to change things a lot more quickly than many current leaders will allow. So do we wait until we run out of water? Or go with the organization that has accepted and embraced the need for drastic changes?

    If your processes are more important than the survival of your organization, then maybe revisiting your mission and values is in order.

  • Julia

    Anonymous said: “All this shows is those who “can do” do, and those who “can’t do” teach.”

    Julia sez: The use of this very quote demonstrates what is wrong with our society. If no one taught, for goodness sake how would people learn? If it satisfies you, Rosetta isn’t just teaching, she is also “doing” (now teaching isn’t doing?-LOL)

    Anonymous said: As a director in a non-profit who did pay the dues, I can tell you that the value of time in roles is invaluable.

    Julia sez: but seriously….of course we will always learn new ways of doing things and have to familiarize ourselves with the ever changing systems….but puhleeze, after a certain point….the learning curve is not as high and this statement even implies that all non-profit “leaders” and senior management have the same commitment to learning…have we not all observed many who are just counting the days until something else comes along…..and sometimes this something else is retirement.

    Anonymous said: “No one should assume that good ideas and raw talent alone prepare you for leadership.”

    Julia sez: Hell, give me good ideas and raw talent over “years put in” any day! The proof is in the pudding, I am tired of this “you’re too young” nonsense when I continuously observe senior management and other “leaders” who are consistently ineffective at what they do….and this observation isn’t merely, an attitude based on “I can do better than they can” but it is based on ineffective programs, unhappy workers, dissatisfied consumers/clients/patients and misuse of resources……..

  • Jonathon Carrington

    I know this is an older post but this really woke me up today! I am 24 going on 40 and I feel the same way! I have also experienced the baby-boomer and Gen X families raining on my parade and shooting me down because I am so goal-driven and a fighter. Over time, I have just learned to ignore it and say, “Ok, thanks for your opinion”, and move on about my merry way and push even harder. I have realized and have accepted that there are two kinds of people in the world: masters of the universe and servants. The ones who do and take advantage of all of the opportunities for growth in the universe will, and the ones who don’t will continue to go through the motions and live their life waiting for the universe to owe them something.

    I mean, what do you have to lose? You make a mistake, so what? You learn from it and move on to bigger and better things. Thank you for writing this and saying what everyone who identifies with you is thinking!

    Good day!

  • http://rosettathurman.com/blog/2009/03/welcome-to-perspectives-from-the-pipeline-a-guide-for-new-readers/ Rosetta Thurman » Welcome to Perspectives From the Pipeline! A Guide for New Readers

    [...] You Wanna Be Startin’ Somethin’: 5 Reasons You Shouldn’t Start Your Own Nonprofit… (11)Break All the Rules… (11)Why I Wish Nonprofits Would Stop Using the Word ‘Minorities’… (11)Blogs as Online Learning [...]

Loading...
Sign up for blog updates and get a FREE chapter of my book, How to Become a Nonprofit Rockstar!