Diversity is the Wrong Word

This morning, I moderated a panel called “Rising Through the Ranks: Race & Gender in Nonprofit Leadership.” The discussion was a joint event between the Nonprofit Roundtable and YNPNdc geared toward emerging leaders in philanthropy and nonprofits.

The conversation opened with Kelly Reid from the National MultiCultural Institute sharing some of the statistics in the Urban Institute’s recent report,  Measuring Racial-Ethnic Diversity in the Baltimore-Washington Region’s Nonprofit Sector. We were joined by a racially and gender diverse panel, including:

Each panelist shared a story about how their leadership experiences in the nonprofit sector have been affected by race and/or gender. It was an amazing discussion and I wish you had been there.

One Really Important Thing that stuck out for me during the conversation was this:

Diversity is very often the wrong word to use when we’re talking about efforts to bring in more people of color or LGBT or men or women into our organizations. We have to get increasingly more specific about what we mean when we say diversity, because we all think something different in our minds when the term is used.

In my case, what I’m usually talking about on my blog is racial justice.

The Applied Research Center defines racial justice this way:

We define racial justice as the proactive reinforcement of policies, practices, attitudes and actions that produce equitable power, opportunities, treatment, impacts and outcomes for all.

I’m talking about inclusion and equality and I’m talking about power. Which is far more complex and involved than diversity. It goes beyond “diversity workshops” and “sensitivity training” and reaches into sector reform, advocacy and policy change.

What many of us do goes way beyond diversity as a blanket concept. But in nonprofit circles, diversity seems to be a much more accessible word for the conversation.

Or is it?

YNPN 2009: Day 1 Conference Recap

State of DC Nonprofit Sector Panel: Moderator Stacey Palmer (Chronicle of Philanthropy), Chuck Bean (Nonprofit Roundtable), Tamara Copeland (Washington Grantmakers), Glen Ogilvie (Center for Nonprofit Advancement)

Thanks for following all the liveblogging coverage here at the YNPN 2009 Annual Leaders Conference in DC.  It’s the end of the day, and I’m just trying to stay awake for happy hour tonight! But before I head out, just wanted to give you a summary of what’s been going on today. Lots of connections made, tons of learning and professional development, the space for young nonprofit leaders to think about our own leadership.

Blogging!

Check out our full #ynpn09 twitter feed from today: http://search.twitter.com/search?q=%23ynpn09

Check out today’s keynote speech by Diana Aviv, President of Independent Sector (recorded by awesome YNPNdc board member Malcolm Furgol)

Check out this short video interview with 2 conference attendees and YNPNdc members.

Check out some photos from today.

Check out all the blog posts written about today’s events:

Blogging!

YNPN 2009 Guest Blog: Khyati Desai, Diana Aviv’s Keynote, Mergers and Multi-Generational Workplaces

Keynote Speech: Diana from Independent Sector

“Knowing others is intelligence. Knowing yourself is true wisdom. Understanding others is strength. Understanding yourself is true power.”

“If you want to walk fast, walk alone. If you want to walk far, walk together”

Nonprofit’s mission is leading, strengthening, and mobilizing our community. In order for nonprofits to truly reach our mission, we have to work together, to collaborate with the experts in the field that can address the various unique needs and challenges of communities across the country. Diana refers to this as the “social ecosystem” affirming that nonprofits also cannot operate as islands. On average, 70,000 nonprofits are created every year. The financial crisis means that this year, 2009, there will be fewer nonprofits at the end of the year.

Human capital is going to be the difference and this sector needs “strong, connected people” in order to accomplish the purposes that are larger than ourselves. This lack of value for human capital is something I personally have both noticed and experienced in my few years of employment in the sector, whether the organization is being led by a young person or a more experienced person and it is here where the organization risks failing. This failure manifests in various ways such as frequent turnover, mission creep, inability to effectively achieve the mission, etc. How can we change this trend instead of feeling like we have to leave these worthy organizations due to a conflict in values and philosophy?

Diana asks us, as nonprofit leaders, to network, to understand our mutual and shared responsibility, to share skills and practices in order to move the needle on the impact we’re making in the world and to challenge ourselves and each other to continue to think in creative and innovative ways on how best to serve our communities.

Closing Session: On Mergers

Funders are addicted to mergers and acquisitions since it mitigates their challenges in selecting a worth nonprofit. They are more interested in nonprofits that create alliances instead of nonprofits that are unique or different. However, instead of merging, share resources, co-locate, etc. in order to reduce costs and stay consistent with values.

On Multi-Generational Workplaces

An organization cannot sustain itself if it is only committed to employing a certain generation of staff to serve as nonprofit leaders. Today, young people feel like they are not valued in their workplace-that they don’t have enough experience and education and so are dismissed. YNPN and other organizations are committed to helping organizations see young staff as leaders now and today, not in 20 or 30 years. On the flip side, boomers and seasoned leaders are feeling like they’re also not valued and they feel pressure to leave the sector to make way for younger staff. And organizations that specialize in experienced employees have invested time and money to protect the interest of boomers. However, a truly effective, balanced workplace is multigenerational-one in which the experience, education, and, in some cases, wisdom of older staff is both necessary and critical so that problems aren’t repeated and lessons learned can be shared. And young people would be valued for their genuine interest in making a contribution, learning, and growing while committing their time, energy, and creativity to their organization. Diversity, not only in race, but also in age and gender can contribute to a reflective, strong, impactful organization.

YNPN 2009 Guest Blog: Khyati Desai, Results from YNPNdc 2008 Survey

by Khyati Desai, YNPN DC 2009 Guest Blogger
Khyati is the Civic Engagement Manager at Points of Light & Hands On Network. She shares her great notes from the YNPN 2009 Panel: The Next Generation of Leadership

Results From the YNPNdc 2008 Survey

I’m not a numbers person but a great Statistics professor in Graduate school turned me on to statistical data in our sector. These are some of the results from the 2008 YNPN survey, which was sent to 2,200 members. Of the 2,200 emailed the community needs assessment, there were 575 responses.

Of those surveyed, 40% of nonprofits in DC are national and 29% are international. 38% plan to stay more than 5 years and 20% for 3-5 years. About 41% have worked 3-5 years and 72% plan and want to stay in the nonprofit sector. Why would people leave?

- Better pay

- Better skill fit

- Offered a position with more responsibility

51% are midlevel staff and 32% are entry level though a proportion are heads and heads of department. 27% are paid between $40-49K. 42% have been employed less than 1 year. 36% plan to stay 1-2 years at their current organization.

In terms of long term career goals, 32% are interested in being a senior leader of a national or international nonprofit, 32% are unsure of their long term goals, and 32% want to work as a consultant for a nonprofit.

Now that’s something to chew on….

YNPN 2009 Guest Blog: Opa Owiye, Fundraising is Not About Thinking Outside the Box

by Opa Owiye, YNPN 2009 Guest Blogger
Opa shares her great notes from the YNPN 2009 Professional Development Workshop: Fundraising in a Tough Economy

Luke Driscoll, Regional VP, CCS Fundraising, Development Services, Strategic Consulting did a great job of giving basic tools for young fundraisers in a tough economy. It seems that there isn’t a secret to fundraising during a difficult economic environment. What he recommended was “thinking inside the box” instead of “thinking outside the box”.

As he put it, the box is there for a reason. In thinking inside the box look at what the best practices are, what’s worked in the past, what’s working now, what’s not working, why it’s not working, and how can we be innovative.

He also gave us a 10 pt. plan for meeting the challenges ahead.

  1. Reaffirm your organizations’ mission and impact
  2. Increase activity especially in cultivation and engagement
  3. Motivate internal leaders that you will remain successful
  4. Encourage your staff to support each other
  5. Increase prospecting to expand your potential donor base
  6. Explore diversification in fundraising
  7. Introduce gift options
  8. Using those you know for prospects, expanding network, helping board
  9. Share the latest philanthropic information to both motivate leadership and temper expectations
  10. Open new doors to longer term prospect cultivation

Lastly, he reiterated the key traits of a successful fundraiser.

  • Belief in the organization and leaders
  • Enthusiasm and passion
  • Sense of urgency
  • Willing to take risks
  • Strategic thinker
  • Sees opportunities, when others see problems
  • Aligns donors/prospects with organization’s needs

So, be encouraged fundraisers! Philanthropy is not a function of the stock market but a function of the gross national product. Philanthropy has never gone down. It has always either gone up or held steady. And, a recent survey by Bank of America showed that majority of people gave simply because they were asked. So, people get out there and ASK!

Loading...
Sign up for blog updates and get a FREE chapter of my book, How to Become a Nonprofit Rockstar!